Movies Like Sinners

Why it fits

• Our pick if you liked Sinners
• Vampire
• Action Horror
• Urban Horror

Streaming on Peacock

Blade is half-vampire and has spent his whole life using that against the species. The vampire underworld he moves through doesn't know what to do with him.

Why it fits

• Our pick if you liked Sinners
• Vampire
• Gothic
• Creature Features

Streaming on Hulu

Thomas Hutter travels to Transylvania to complete a real estate transaction with Count Orlok. The consequences follow him home to Wisborg and his wife Ellen.

Why it fits

• Our pick if you liked Sinners
• Vampire
• Small Town Horror
• Religious Horror

Streaming on HBO Max

Ben Mears returns to Jerusalem's Lot after decades away and finds that a recent arrival in an old house has been systematically working through the town.

Why it fits

• Our pick if you liked Sinners
• Religious Horror
• Supernatural

Streaming on HBO Max

Ed and Lorraine Warren are called to examine a Rhode Island farmhouse and find the family has been living with something for years.

Why it fits

• Paired with Sinners in our reviews
• Vampire
• Action Horror
• Urban Horror

Streaming on Netflix

Bud Jablonski, a vampire slayer with a side business at a local car wash, is forced to partner with a crew of hunters for a single night's work in the San Fernando Valley.

Why it fits

• Paired with Sinners in our reviews
• Vampire
• Gothic
• Creature Features

Abigail is taken as leverage by a crew hired to hold her for ransom overnight. The team discovers over the course of the night that their target is significantly more dangerous than they were briefed.

Why it fits

• Paired with Sinners in our reviews
• Action Horror
• Urban Horror
• Supernatural

Streaming on HBO Max

They Will Kill You blurs the line between documentation and horror fiction in ways that make the threat feel present rather than constructed.

Why it fits

• Southern Gothic
• Religious Horror
• Gothic

Streaming on Peacock, Tubi

Reverend Cotton Marcus agrees to let a documentary crew film an exorcism he believes will prove the practice is fraudulent. Nell Sweetzer becomes his subject.

Why it fits

• Action Horror
• Gothic
• Urban Horror

Streaming on Peacock, Paramount+

A year to the night after a gang murders him and the woman he was about to marry, a young rocker climbs out of his grave with a crow at his shoulder and a list of names. Detroit's rain-slicked rooftops become his hunting ground.

Why it fits

• Vampire
• Gothic
• Urban Horror

Streaming on Tubi

Lestat wakes from a long sleep, becomes a rock star, and draws the attention of an ancient vampire queen who's been dormant for centuries.