Curated collection

Curated Underrated Horror Movies and Games

Underrated horror means movies and games whose quality outstrips their reputation, titles most genre fans still haven't heard of or wrote off too quickly. Not every great horror film got a wide release, a marketing budget, or a second chance. Some just disappeared. This is the list for those films, curated hidden gems in horror that slipped through the cracks but never lost their edge. They're here because they earned it.

Advanced filters21–40 of 77
Official promotional artwork for Detektiv

Detective Fyodor Mikhailovich investigates a strange murder. A fifteen-minute horror experience built around a single crime scene.

HorrorMysteryShort
Poster artwork for Dr. Giggles

Dr. Giggles

1992 · Movie

Evan Rendell has grown up with his father's obsession and is now loose in a suburb where a teenager is dealing with a heart condition.

1990sSlasherHorror Comedy
Official promotional artwork for Drive Me to Hell

Drive Me to Hell

2024 · Game

Driving home at night, something unsettling happens on the road. Whether it leads you to hell depends on what you choose to do about it.

ActionAdventureRacing
Poster artwork for Ed and His Dead Mother

Ed Chilton misses his mother badly enough to pay a mysterious salesman to bring her back. She comes back hungry.

1990sDark ComedyZombie
Poster artwork for Evil Ed

Evil Ed

1995 · Movie
Pick

A mild-mannered film editor is reassigned to cut a series of violent splatter films and sent off to a country cottage alone to do the work. The footage changes him.

1990sHorror ComedySplatter
Official promotional artwork for EXTR

EXTR

Game

Run, neutralize, extract. A short horror game about synthesizing and neutralizing biological objects using a universal computer system.

HorrorShortSingleplayer
Official promotional artwork for Fear the Flesh

An Antarctic research team discovers a perfectly preserved meteorite and runs a late-night experiment that goes catastrophically wrong.

Adventure3DAtmospheric
Official promotional artwork for Fears to Fathom - Norwood Hitchhike

Holly Gardner is nineteen, on an interstate drive, when unusual events lead to an unplanned stay at a motel. What's happening in Norwood Valley is worse than she knows.

AdventureIndieInteractive Fiction
Official promotional artwork for Follower

Mitch makes a quick errand stop on a snowy night in Davenburg. The streets feel wrong and whatever's behind him confirms it.

HorrorAtmosphericWalking Simulator
Official promotional artwork for Fractured Blooms

A cozy life-sim wrapped inside a horror time loop where daily routines keep resetting and something underneath the comfort refuses to let go.

AdventureRPGSimulation
Poster artwork for Halloween III: Season of the Witch

No Michael Myers. Instead, a California coastal town is being targeted by a mask company with a very strange plan for Halloween night.

1980sHoliday HorrorFolk Horror
Poster artwork for House at the End of the Street

Sarah moves in next door to a house where something happened that the community has not fully processed.

2010sQueer HorrorFamily Horror
Poster artwork for Ice Cream Man

Ice Cream Man

1995 · Movie

The neighborhood ice cream man has a very disturbing operation running out of his truck, and the local kids are starting to notice.

1990sSlasherHorror Comedy
Official promotional artwork for Is Guilty

Is Guilty

2026 · Game

Night shift at a lonely drive-thru coffee stand. A mysterious email arrives and changes everything about what your job actually is.

AdventureIndieSimulation
Poster artwork for Jack Frost

Jack Frost

1997 · Movie

A serial killer dies in a chemical accident en route to his execution and comes back as a sentient, murderous snowman with specific targets in mind.

1990sHoliday HorrorSlasher
Poster artwork for Jack's Back

Jack's Back

1988 · Movie
Pick

A copycat killer starts recreating Jack the Ripper's murders exactly one hundred years later, and a young doctor becomes the prime suspect. His identical twin knows he's innocent, and starts seeing things that suggest something far stranger is going on.

1980sPsychologicalSerial Killer
Poster artwork for Killer Nerd

Killer Nerd

1991 · Movie

Harold Kunkle gets mocked at work, harassed by punks on the street, and rejected by the coworker he's fallen for. His self-help tapes on how to be cool don't help nearly as much as the killing spree does.

1990sSlasherDark Comedy
Poster artwork for Ma

Ma

2019 · Movie

Sue Ann, a veterinary assistant, befriends a group of teenagers and hosts parties in her basement. The situation's imbalance becomes clear gradually.

2010sSlasherPsychological
Poster artwork for Marrowbone

Marrowbone

2017 · Movie

In 1968, a mother flees England with her four children for her childhood home in rural Maine. When she dies, the children start experiencing things they can't explain.

2010sPsychologicalInternational Horror
Official promotional artwork for Memories To Kill - The Silent Chalet

Evelyn inherits a mountain chalet from her father and arrives to find herself caught in a relentless blizzard. The silence inside is louder than the storm.

AdventureIndieHorror